Ask ten Amazon sellers why a product became successful and the answers sound remarkably similar. It had high demand. It ranked well. It had few competitors. The margins were good. The listing was optimised.
This audio is AI-generated with NotebookLM from this article.
None of those answers are wrong. They’re simply incomplete — because products don’t become successful in isolation. They succeed because they exist inside systems: of customer behaviour, supply chains, economics, competition, technology.
Experienced operators stop asking “is this a good product?” and start asking “what system produced this opportunity?”
Products are outcomes. Systems are causes.
Imagine standing beneath a tree. An apple falls and you catch it. If your goal is to eat apples, your work is finished. But suppose your goal is to build an orchard.
Suddenly the apple isn’t the interesting part. The roots are. The soil, the weather, the irrigation, the insects, the ecosystem. The apple is merely the visible outcome of a much larger system.
Products work exactly the same way. They are visible. The forces that created them are not.
Most product research studies symptoms
Imagine a product suddenly doubles in sales.
What is the search volume? How many reviews? Who are the competitors?
Why are more customers buying? What changed? How durable is whatever caused it?
One studies results. The other studies causes.
Imagine watching the ocean
You notice waves crashing onto the shore. You could spend years measuring wave height, wave speed, wave frequency. Useful information.
But eventually someone asks what is creating the waves — wind, currents, tides, weather systems, the moon — and the investigation changes completely.
Amazon businesses often spend enormous effort measuring waves while ignoring the ocean.
Products live inside multiple systems
Take something as simple as an ergonomic office chair. Its performance isn’t determined by one factor.
Every product sits at the intersection of dozens of systems. Ignoring them means misunderstanding the product itself.
Competition is a system
Most sellers treat competitors as static: count listings, compare prices, read reviews, done. Experienced businesses ask why these competitors entered, how they make money, what constraints they have, what advantages they possess, what happens if margins decline, and which of them are likely to leave.
Competition is dynamic. Companies continuously respond to one another, and every decision changes the environment. Understanding that interaction is usually worth more than studying individual competitors.
Imagine a forest
A forest isn’t simply a collection of trees. Remove one species and the insects change, bird populations change, soil changes, water changes.
Nothing happens independently.
Customer behaviour is a system
Suppose sales suddenly decline. Many sellers immediately investigate listings, keywords, advertising and pricing. Sometimes the real explanation lives elsewhere — economic uncertainty, changing lifestyles, new regulations, different purchasing priorities, emerging technologies, shifting values.
Products don’t simply compete against other products. They compete against changing human behaviour.
Supply chains are living systems
Many founders think about suppliers transactionally: place order, receive inventory, repeat. Reality is more complex. Manufacturing capacity changes. Labour markets change. Currencies fluctuate. Governments intervene. Transportation evolves. Raw materials become scarce. Technology improves.
Systems rarely fail all at once. They weaken gradually, which is exactly why they need watching continuously rather than at reorder time.
Imagine looking at Amazon like a biologist
Biologists don’t study one animal. They study ecosystems: relationships, adaptation, evolution, feedback loops, natural selection.
Amazon is remarkably similar. Customer behaviour evolves. Competition evolves. Advertising evolves. Technology evolves. Businesses evolve. Static thinking struggles in dynamic environments; systems thinking thrives.
Every metric belongs to something larger
Revenue, margins, conversion rate, TACoS, inventory turns, customer lifetime value — each is usually treated independently. Yet every one influences the others.
Increase advertising. Revenue increases. Inventory declines faster. Working capital requirements rise. Stockout risk increases. Organic ranking changes. Profitability shifts.
One metric never moves alone. Understanding the relationships matters more than optimising any individual number.
Feedback loops create winners — and destroy businesses
- Positive reviews improve ranking
- Better ranking increases sales
- Higher sales improve purchasing power
- Better purchasing power lowers costs
- Lower costs improve margins
- Higher margins allow better advertising
- Advertising increases sales again
- Inventory shortages reduce sales
- Lower sales reduce cash flow
- Poor cash flow delays inventory purchases
- Longer delays create larger stockouts
- Advertising becomes less efficient
- Organic ranking declines
- Revenue falls further
Many businesses don’t collapse because of one mistake. They become trapped inside a negative loop, and recognising one early is a major competitive advantage.
The best product researchers study constraints
Every system has them: production capacity, cash, management attention, supplier relationships, advertising inventory, warehouse space, human expertise.
Products don’t fail because constraints exist. They fail because businesses ignore them. Systems thinking begins by asking what limits this system, and how those limits will change over time.
Imagine playing chess instead of checkers
Checkers rewards immediate moves. Chess rewards understanding relationships, because every move changes future possibilities.
Product research is much closer to chess. Launching one product changes supplier leverage, inventory planning, advertising, future expansion, customer perception, brand identity and operational complexity. Products don’t simply add revenue — they reshape the system.
The dashboard we actually need
Imagine opening your analytics platform and seeing relationships instead of isolated metrics:
- How advertising influences inventory
- How inventory influences profitability
- How profitability influences expansion
- How expansion influences complexity
- How complexity influences forecasting
- How forecasting influences cash flow
Dashboards built around connections instead of categories. The goal would no longer be reporting. It would be understanding.
AI will analyse products. Humans must analyse systems.
Artificial intelligence is becoming extraordinarily good at identifying patterns, estimating demand, predicting sales, monitoring competitors and optimising advertising. Those tasks increasingly become automated.
What remains difficult is understanding systems: recognising changing incentives, connecting unrelated trends, evaluating long-term consequences, thinking across disciplines. That’s where human judgement continues creating extraordinary value.
Final thoughts
Amazon businesses naturally encourage product thinking. Launch another SKU. Improve another listing. Optimise another campaign. Track another metric. Those activities matter, but they rarely explain why some businesses consistently outperform over long periods.
The strongest companies understand that products aren’t isolated opportunities. They’re visible expressions of much larger systems — customer, economic, operational, behavioural, competitive.
Every successful product tells a story, not just about itself but about the environment that made its success possible. Experienced founders learn to read those stories.
Products eventually disappear. Markets evolve, algorithms change, competitors improve. Systems remain — and companies that understand them rarely need to chase opportunities. They recognise them first.
The future of product research won’t belong to the businesses with the most data. It will belong to those that best understand the invisible forces connecting that data together. Because products are temporary, systems are enduring, and understanding systems is one of the few advantages that becomes stronger every year you stay in business.
This is the widest lens in the Product Research set. For the same idea applied to an organisation rather than a market, see your business is producing exactly what it was designed to produce. See also winning markets and risk research.
Episode transcript
Read the full transcript
Transcribed automatically from the recording. Speakers are not labelled.
What changes when I ask about the system instead of the product?
[00:00]Welcome to the deep dive. Today, um, we are focusing on a single Fascinating source that completely shifts how you should look at building a business Especially on Amazon right particularly on Amazon our mission today is to unpack this article from AmazeBase It's titled most sellers analyze products Great companies analyze systems Yeah, that title really says it all it really does because we are gonna explore Why the biggest competitive advantage in e-commerce it just isn't about finding better products anymore It's about understanding the invisible operating systems that actually produce those products. So alright, let's unpack this Yeah, because the premise requires a fundamental change in the actual questions you ask.
Like how so? Well, the traditional approach in e-commerce and really in any retail environment, honestly, is to look at a market and ask, is this a good product? Right. But experienced, highly successful businesses, they look at the exact same market and they ask, what system produced this opportunity? Oh, wow. I mean, it is the difference between wanting to eat an apple and wanting to build an orchard. That's a great way to put it. Because imagine you're standing beneath this massive apple tree, right? You look up, you wait, and suddenly a perfectly ripe apple just falls into your hands.
You got lucky. Exactly. And if your only goal is to eat an apple, you are entirely successful, like your work is done. Right. But if you wanna build an orchard that produces thousands of apples year after year, just staring at the branches isn't gonna cut it. You have to look down. You have to study the roots. The soil composition, the weather patterns, the irrigation, the insects, all of it. Yeah, because the apple is merely the visible outcome. The entire biological ecosystem that produced it, that is the hidden cause. I love that. And a product on a digital shelf is no different. It's an outcome. Another way to visualize this, and the source text actually brings this up, is standing on a beach watching the ocean. Okay. You know, you can spend years meticulously measuring the height of the waves crashing onto the shore.
Why is tracking a product's numbers like measuring the waves?
[02:05]Just standing there with a ruler. Right, exactly. You could measure their speed, their frequency, the exact angle they hit the sand. Which honestly is pretty much what the average Amazon seller is doing all day long. Yeah, they are. They see a product suddenly double in sales and they just immediately measure the waves. They check the search volume, they count the reviews, they look at competitor pricing. They analyze the keyword ranking.
Right. They're obsessing over the metrics attached to the product itself. And I mean, that data is useful if your only goal is to surf that specific wave today. Sure. But eventually, a systems thinker comes along and asks, what is actually creating these waves? And that changes the entire investigation. Because you stop looking at the water right in front of you.
Exactly. You start studying the wind patterns, ocean currents, global weather systems, even the gravitational pull of the moon. Right. Because products do not become successful in a vacuum. No, they don't. They exist inside these massive overlapping systems of customer behavior, global supply chains, macroeconomics, shifting technology. So just to make sure I'm following, if a product suddenly doubles in sales, a normal seller cheers because the keyword ranking went up.
Right. High fives all around. But a systems thinker asks what fundamental human behavior or economic shift actually caused the ranking to go up? Well, what's fascinating here is that ignoring those root causes guarantees you will always be reacting. It's like taking medicine to lower a fever without ever asking what infection caused the fever in the first place. That is exactly it. You are treating the product as if it's an independent entity and this leads directly into a massive operational trap.
What is the trap of improving one dashboard at a time?
Which is? The illusion of local optimization. Okay. I am trying to picture how this trap actually works in practice. Because on paper, if I have a dashboard for advertising and like a dashboard for inventory, and I make a decision that improves my advertising metrics, my assumption is that I just helped the business. Where is the invisible trap door there? Well, it opens up when we forget that a business is an interconnected web. It's not a series of isolated columns. Sellers often treat operations as separate problems to solve.
How can spending more on ads leave me worse off?
[04:19]They think they have an advertising problem, a purchasing problem, a cash flow problem. But they don't. Right, because those departments all share inputs. Let's walk through a very common sequence from the AmazeBase piece. Let's do it. You look at a specific SKU and you decide to increase your advertising budget for it.
Because it's doing well. Right, and locally on that specific dashboard, it looks brilliant. The ads run, your ACOS, your advertising cost of sales looks profitable, and your revenue for that product increases. Sales are up. Everything looks great. But follow the invisible threads of that decision. Because revenue increased, your inventory is now declining much faster than you originally forecasted. Oh, I see where this is going. Right. Because inventory is depleting rapidly. You have to place a new purchase order sooner than expected Which means that suddenly raises your working capital requirements your cash is tied up weeks ahead of schedule meaning I might not have the cash on hand actually afford the full reorder or I Have to siphon capital away from another product's inventory just to feed this one. Exactly. Okay.
Which means your initial, quote unquote, successful ad spend just increased your overall stock out risk across the entire business. Wow. And if you do stock out, your organic ranking for that product drops. Right. So when the dust settles, your overall profitability has shifted and you are in a worse financial position than before you increased the ad budget.
Shouldn't I push a winning product as hard as I can?
That is wild. What looked like a rational data-driven decision at the SKU level actually created a cascading cash flow crunch for the whole company. I see the logic there. I really do. But I have to push back on this a little bit. Go for it. If I have a winning product, like a SKU that is just crushing it, surely I shouldn't just throttle it, right? I mean, if the demand is there, leaving money on the table feels like a cardinal sin in retail. It does. It's the natural instinct.
[06:14]Right. There has to be a middle ground where you push the winner without breaking the supply chain. Well, you want to capture market share, I get that. But the nuance here is that you cannot capture market share if you lack the systemic capacity to support it. Ah, okay. Pushing a winner is only profitable if your system can absorb the shock waves of that push. The shock waves. Yeah. Consider the ergonomic office chair example from the AmazeBase analysis. Oh yeah, I remember this part. It seems like a simple isolated product, right? You sit in it, you sell it. But the demand for that specific chair doesn't just depend on whether your Amazon listing has, like, high-resolution photos and good bullet points.
Far from it. The performance of that chair relies on remote work trends. It is impacted by interest rates affecting commercial real estate, corporate budgets, global manufacturing capacity, the cost of raw plastic and steel, shipping routes, shipping routes, algorithm changes. Every single product sits at the intersection of dozens of massive systems. So when I say, hey, I'm going to maximize ad spend on this chair because it's converting really well. I am completely ignoring the fact that my capital constraints, my warehouse space, my shipping containers, they are all shared across my entire catalog.
Exactly. Optimizing that single advertising metric in a vacuum basically assumes the rest of the world will just passively accommodate my decision to sell more chairs. Right. And the world doesn't work like that. Businesses are dynamic ecosystems. You pull one lever and three other levers move on their own.
How does a reinforcing loop make a business stronger?
Right. Which brings us to the most critical mechanism of systems thinking, which is feedback loops. See, here's where it gets really interesting to me, because it isn't a straight line from cause to effect. No, it's a loop. It's like a complex engine where all the gears are shared. You can't just spin the advertising gear twice as fast where the cash flow gear won't just shatter if they aren't synced up.
[08:09]That's a perfect analogy. Systems rely on these feedback loops and they generally fall into two categories. Okay. You have reinforcing loops and vicious loops. Let's start with the good one. Yeah. Reinforcing loops. They create massive compounding success. It starts with one positive input that feeds the next.
Like what? Like you get a batch of positive customer reviews. Those reviews improve your organic conversion rate. A higher conversion rate naturally increases your daily sales velocity. And because I have higher sales volume, I can go to my manufacturer and negotiate better purchasing terms.
Exactly. Oh. You are ordering larger quantities, so your cost per unit goes down. Lower costs immediately improve my profit margins. Yep. And with higher margins, you suddenly have more free cash flow to allocate toward better, more aggressive advertising. Which increases the sales again. Starting the whole cycle over from a much stronger position.
How does the same loop run in reverse?
The system reinforces itself. Every step makes the next step easier. But the dangerous part is that this exact same mechanism works in reverse, doesn't it? Oh, absolutely. The exact same invisible connections can just consume a business from the inside out. The vicious loop is terrifying.
Yeah. And it's terrifying because it rarely announces itself. It often starts with a single seemingly minor disruption. Like what? Let's say, let's say you experience a slight inventory delay at the port. Okay. It reduces your sales for just a couple of weeks. But lower sales mean you collect less revenue, which tightly constricts your available cash flow. Which means when it is time to pay the deposit for the next manufacturing run, the cash isn't in the bank yet.
What does a stockout do to my ranking and ad costs?
Right. So the purchase order gets delayed. And that minor shipping delay has now morphed into a massive extended stock out. Oof. And this is where we have to look at the mechanics of the platform itself. Let's look at the Amazon A10 algorithm, for example. Okay, let's talk about the algorithm. When you go out of stock, it isn't just a pause button on your business. The algorithm relies on rolling sales history and conversion rate momentum. It needs that constant feed.
[10:14]Right. When your inventory hits zero, the machine learning models lose their data feed. Your competitors absorb the clicks and sales that would have been yours, which improves their historical weight. So when my inventory finally arrives, like three weeks later, I don't just pick up where I left off.
Not at all. The algorithm basically treats my product as unproven all over again. Exactly. To regain that lost rank, you have to spend significantly more on pay per click advertising. But because your ads lost their historical performance data, your cost per click is higher and your campaigns are way less efficient. So you're spending more money to get fewer sales.
Why is my business connected like a forest?
Right. And because your ads are inefficient, your profit margins shrink. And shrinking margins mean less cash flow for the next order. Wow. The system is literally eating itself alive. If we connect this to the bigger picture, it mirrors biology. Right. Like the AmazeBase article was saying about the forest. Yes. You cannot remove one species of insect from a forest without changing the bird population. Right. And if the birds change, the soil composition changes. If the soil changes, the water retention of the forest changes.
Everything is connected. In an e-commerce business, lowering your prices increases demand. Higher demand stresses your suppliers. Supplier delays increase your inventory pressure. Inventory shortages destroy your algorithmic ranking. Which drives up your advertising costs. And higher advertising costs force you to alter your pricing again.
Why do businesses collapse slowly instead of all at once?
Nothing happens independently. It makes complete sense why the source text emphasizes that businesses rarely collapse from one massive catastrophic mistake. Right, they don't just wake up one day and decide to fail. No. They collapse because they get trapped inside one of these vicious self-consuming loops. And they don't even realize it until the cash is completely gone. Because they view their supply chain and their daily operations as a series of static isolated transactions rather than this living, breathing organism. Which brings us to the ultimate question for an operator. If average sellers are blinding themselves by looking at isolated products, how do the greatest operators actually navigate this complexity? How do they purposefully build reinforcing loops while avoiding the vicious ones?
Why is running the business more like chess than checkers?
[12:28]Well, it seems to come down to how they view the rules of the game they are playing. The text uses a really good analogy here, Checkers vs. Chess. Oh, I love this part. Checkers rewards immediate reactive capture, right? You see an opening, you take it. You launch a new SKU. You optimize a PPC campaign. You drop a price to win a lightning deal. Exactly. It is all about immediate gratification and isolated moves. Chess, however, rewards a deep understanding of relationships.
Because every move matters. In chess, every single move you make permanently changes the future possibilities of every other piece on the board. So launching a new product isn't just adding a piece to the board to get more revenue. No. It changes my leverage with my supplier. It alters my warehouse inventory planning. It dilutes my advertising budget. It reshapes the entire system. And it changes how you evaluate competition too.
How should I size up a competitor?
How so? Well, great companies do not waste time counting competitor listings or obsessing over slight price variations. Because that treats competitors as static objects. Right. Instead, systems thinkers analyze a competitor's constraints. Ooh, that's so smart. They are looking for the invisible limits of the other guy's system.
Exactly. They ask, "Why did this competitor enter the market in the first place? How are they actually structuring their cash flow? What are their warehouse constraints? Right. Consider what happens to a competitor's business model if the cost of raw materials goes up by, say, 10%. Do they have the margin to absorb it? Or will their system break?
Wow. Understanding the dynamic interaction between companies and the constraints of their supply chains is worth infinitely more than just studying a static list of their product features. Totally. I want to transition into what might actually be the most urgent takeaway from all of this.
What will AI take over, and what stays human?
Okay. Because we are operating in a world right now where artificial intelligence is completely rewriting the rules of commerce. Oh, absolutely. And the text makes a profound point about this AI divide that is splitting the industry right now. Because AI is becoming extraordinarily good at doing exactly what product focus sellers spend all their time doing. The pattern recognition capabilities of modern AI are just staggering.
[14:37]It's crazy. It can estimate search demand. It can predict sales velocity, adjust pricing dynamically, and optimize ad bids in real time, literally 24 hours a day. So AI is essentially mastering the study of symptoms. Yes, it is mastering the what. So if a human operator's entire skill set is logging into a dashboard, reading a metric, and tweaking a bid, their value is dropping toward zero very quickly.. The AI will always be faster at measuring the waves. It really will. The AI will find the patterns and the data instantly, but the enduring value of human operators lies in analyzing the systems. Because human judgment is still required. Right. It's required to evaluate the long-term second- order consequences of a decision across all these different disciplines. AI can tell you that search volume for a specific aesthetic is up. Exactly. But a human systems thinker connects that search volume to a shifting cultural trend. They evaluate how that impacts overseas supplier relations. And they anticipate how domestic competitors will react six months from now.
Humans have to recognize changing behavioral incentives. Yes. It's like the AI is capable of doing all the complex math, but the human still has to write the underlying physics equation. That's a great way to put it. The future of strategy does not belong to the businesses that simply hoard the most data. Because data is becoming a commodity. Everyone will have access to incredible data. The future belongs to the operators who understand the invisible forces connecting that data together. AI identifies the correlation. Humans must identify the causality.
What does this mean for my business today?
So what does this all mean for you? Whether you are prepping for a marketing meeting, analyzing a new industry investment, or, you know, running your own brand right now, the era of isolated product-level dashboard reporting is ending. It really is. The goal is no longer just reporting metrics in separate columns to see if an apple fell from the tree. No. The goal is understanding the ecosystem.
[16:40]Because products are temporary. Markets evolve, consumer tastes shift, Amazon's search algorithms update and new competitors arrive. But systems are enduring. The underlying systems of human behavioral economics, capital constraints and operational feedback loops, those remain constant. If you understand the mechanics of the system, you never have to chase fleeting opportunities. You will recognize the conditions that create them before the opportunity even fully forms. We spend so much time waiting for something to break to finally pay attention to it. But I want to leave you with a thought to mull over, especially considering where technology is heading.
If AI eventually learns to map these complex interconnected systems, just as well as human operators do. If the software can eventually predict the feedback loops and the supply chain constraints perfectly, what becomes the ultimate competitive advantage then? That's the real question. Does business just become a blunt force game of who has access to the most capital to feed the machine? Or will there always be a uniquely human blind spot in the data that we have to find? Take a hard look at your own projects, your own team, or your own business right now.
Are you watching the invisible connections to see where the stress is building? Or are you just measuring the waves? Thank you for joining us on this deep dive. Keep looking for the systems and we will see you next time.