Product Research

Why Amazon Sellers Overestimate TAM (And Why Smaller Markets Often Build Bigger Businesses)

The biggest market isn’t always the best opportunity. In fact, for many experienced Amazon sellers, it’s exactly the opposite.

AmazeBase 6 min read Product Research

A vast TAM ocean beside the small harbour a business can actually win

Open almost any product research tool and one metric stands out: monthly search volume. The larger the number, the more exciting the opportunity appears. 200,000 searches. 500,000. A million.

Podcast episode 18 minutes 20 seconds

This audio is AI-generated with NotebookLM from this article.

Three nested rings. The outer ring, the total addressable market, is crowded with competitors. The middle ring holds fewer. The small inner ring, where a business actually operates, holds one. TAMSAMSOM THE NUMBER IN THE TOOL Total demand that theoretically exists. WHAT YOU COULD SERVE After geography, channel, price and fit. WHERE YOUR BUSINESS ACTUALLY LIVES What you can realistically win, and hold.

The assumption is obvious — large market equals large opportunity. It feels intuitive. If more people are searching, more people can buy.

Yet some of the most valuable businesses were built by deliberately ignoring the largest markets and becoming indispensable inside much smaller ones. That seems counterintuitive, until you understand what market size actually measures.

Market size is not opportunity

Suppose someone tells you a category is worth a billion dollars. Sounds attractive. Now ask a different question: how many companies already want that billion dollars? How sophisticated are they? How much capital do they have? How optimised are their supply chains, their brands, their advertising systems?

What the number tells you

Market size tells you how much money currently exists. Opportunity depends on how much remains available. Those are not the same thing.

Imagine opening a coffee shop

You have two choices. Open in the busiest commercial district in the city, or open in a growing neighbourhood with fewer customers and almost no serious competition.

Most entrepreneurs instinctively choose the first. Experienced business owners pause, because the busiest street also attracts the strongest competitors: higher rents, higher expectations, more experienced operators, more expensive marketing, thinner margins.

Sometimes the smaller neighbourhood creates a much better business. Amazon categories behave the same way.

Big markets attract big companies

Success leaves footprints, and the larger the market the more visible they become: large brands, private equity, aggregators, international manufacturers, agencies, data scientists, sophisticated pricing algorithms, advanced inventory systems, experienced operators.

Entering an enormous market isn’t simply competing for customers. It’s competing against organisations with years of accumulated advantages. That doesn’t make success impossible — it changes the economics dramatically.

Small markets are often misunderstood

Imagine a category generating ten million dollars a year. Many sellers dismiss it immediately as too small. But ask another question: how much revenue does your business actually need?

If your goal is a company generating five million a year, that market may indeed be too small. If your goal is a business generating a million in annual profit, the same market might be extraordinary.

The correction

Market size should be evaluated relative to your objectives. Not someone else’s.

Most sellers confuse TAM with SOM

TAMTotal Addressable Market The total theoretical demand. The number that makes a category look exciting.
SAMServiceable Available Market The portion you could realistically serve, once geography, channel, price and fit are accounted for.
SOMServiceable Obtainable Market The portion you can realistically capture and hold. This is where your business actually lives.

Amazon sellers frequently stop at TAM, because the largest number feels exciting. Yet businesses survive inside SOM. Your company doesn’t need the entire market — it needs enough of the right customers.

Imagine fishing in the ocean

One fisherman chooses the largest ocean in the world. Another chooses a smaller lake with very little competition. Which catches more fish?

The answer depends on far more than the amount of water: fish density, competition, knowledge, equipment, access, conditions. Markets behave similarly. The amount of demand matters. The amount of accessible demand matters much more.

Large markets hide smaller communities

Consider fitness. Enormous, and extremely competitive. Now look closer.

One category, ten ecosystems
  • Powerlifters
  • Yoga instructors
  • Physical therapists
  • Rock climbers
  • CrossFit athletes
  • Triathletes
  • Rehabilitation patients
  • Senior mobility
  • Postpartum fitness
  • Adaptive sports

Each has its own language, purchasing behaviour, influencers and opportunities.

Experienced companies often dominate communities before attempting to dominate categories.

Niche expertise compounds faster

Suppose your company serves commercial bakeries. After five years you understand customer workflows, regulations, suppliers, seasonality, operational challenges, emerging technologies, replacement cycles and competitor weaknesses.

Now imagine serving random consumer categories instead. Knowledge accumulates far more slowly. Expertise compounds inside focused markets, not broad ones.

Customers don’t buy market size. They buy trust.

One hidden advantage of smaller markets is credibility. People notice specialists.

Imagine buying climbing equipment. Would you rather purchase from a brand that sells everything, or one known exclusively for serving climbers? The specialist immediately feels more trustworthy.

The chain

Focus creates authority. Authority creates pricing power. Pricing power creates extraordinary businesses.

The largest categories often have the lowest margins

Large demand attracts investment. Investment improves competition. Competition compresses margins. Advertising becomes more expensive. Customer expectations increase. Operational standards rise.

The biggest markets are frequently the least forgiving. Smaller markets often allow healthier returns, because fewer competitors possess specialised knowledge.

Imagine reading Amazon backwards

The usual question

“Where are the most customers?”

The one that changes research

“Where are the most underserved customers?”

Demand matters. Unmet demand matters far more.

The goal isn’t market share. It’s market leadership.

1% of a massive market

No recognition, no word of mouth, no supplier influence, no pricing flexibility. You are one of hundreds.

30% of a focused market

Brand recognition, repeat purchasing, supplier influence, customer trust, pricing power, operational expertise.

Small markets make leadership attainable. Large markets often make it elusive.

Small markets can expand naturally

One misconception about niche businesses is that they eventually stop growing. Often the opposite happens.

Imagine beginning with products for professional barbers. Eventually opportunities emerge: salon furniture, cleaning systems, storage, scheduling accessories, training equipment, retail products, professional apparel.

The original market becomes a foundation rather than a limitation. Growth happens through adjacent opportunities instead of random expansion.

The dashboard we actually need

Imagine evaluating a market and seeing, instead of search volume, estimated revenue, a competition score and a seller count:

  • Customer concentration
  • Brand loyalty
  • Pricing power
  • Repeat purchase frequency
  • Supplier specialisation
  • Advertising efficiency
  • Barrier to entry
  • Knowledge advantage
  • Expansion opportunities
  • Market fragmentation

Suddenly small markets begin looking very different.

Great businesses become famous somewhere first

Very few successful brands began by serving everyone. They became indispensable to someone — one profession, one hobby, one community, one lifestyle, one industry — and only later expanded.

Dominating a focused market creates capabilities generalists struggle to imitate. That’s how small markets quietly produce large businesses.

Final thoughts

Amazon sellers naturally gravitate toward the biggest opportunities: the largest search volumes, the highest estimated revenues, the broadest categories. Those numbers are impressive. They also attract everyone else.

Experienced operators eventually realise the objective isn’t finding the biggest market. It’s finding the market where they can create the greatest advantage. Sometimes that sits inside a category worth billions. Often it sits inside a specialised community most competitors ignore.

Because businesses aren’t built by serving the largest number of people. They’re built by solving meaningful problems better than anyone else.

The question that leads somewhere else

Not “how big is this market?” but “can we become the best company in this market?”

One question encourages chasing opportunity wherever it appears. The other encourages building expertise, trust and durable advantage.

Ironically, companies that become exceptional inside small markets often discover something unexpected: their market wasn’t actually small. Their definition of it was. And by the time everyone else notices, they already own it.

Related reading

This narrows what winning markets argues for — that piece says choose a market, this one says choose a smaller one than you think. See also the best products don’t look exciting on why attention and opportunity rarely coincide, and the wrong data on the metrics that mislead.

Episode transcript

Read the full transcript

Transcribed automatically from the recording. Speakers are not labelled.

Is a huge search volume really a goldmine?

[00:00]Imagine you're sitting at your computer, right? Okay. You're staring at a product research tool You type in a keyword hit enter and boom there it is a monthly search volume of like 500,000. Oh, yeah, maybe even a million and your heart rate goes up It feels like you've just uncovered an absolute goldmine. It's an exciting feeling for sure because I mean the logic seems flawless, right? If there are a million people searching for this thing, there's got to be an endless stream of buyers.

But what if chasing that massive headline number is exactly why you are going to fail? That is the really brutal reality we see all the time. And that is exactly what we're tackling today. Welcome to the deep dive. Our mission today is based on this fascinating framework from AmazeBase titled, why Amazon sellers overestimate TAM. And we are going to completely rewire how you look at market size. It really requires a fundamental shift in perspective.

What do TAM, SAM and SOM actually mean?

Yeah. Cause we're going to unpack why that giant headline number is a trap, the critical difference between total demand and the portion you can actually capture. And why a tiny fragmented sub market might actually be your absolute best economic opportunity. The prevailing wisdom is always that bigger is better. But when you look at the mechanics of market concentration, the biggest opportunities often just hide in plain sight inside the smallest numbers. Right. So I want to start with the foundational acronyms the framework brings up, because I feel like this is where the illusion begins. TAM, SAM, and SOM.

The classics. Right. So TAM is total addressable market. SOM is serviceable, obtainable market. And I kind of understand the two extremes. Like, "TAM is the giant ocean of money. SOM is what actually goes in my pocket." But honestly, I am completely struggling with that middle one. SAM, the serviceable, available market.

[01:56]Yes, SAM. How does that actually bridge the gap between the total universe of buyers and the specific customers I can actually reach? Well, it helps to view them as a series of increasingly aggressive filters. Let's, um, let's step away from e-commerce for a second to visualize it.

Okay. I like analogies. If you want to open a specialty coffee shop, your TAM, the total addressable market, is every single human being on the planet who purchases coffee. Which is billions of people. Right. So it is a completely meaningless number for your daily operations. But it shows the global demand.

Got it. Then the SAM, your serviceable available market, applies your physical and geographic reality to that demand. Oh, okay. So your SAM is the population of coffee drinkers who live or work within, say, a five mile radius of your specific city block. They are the people you can technically service. Okay, so TAM is the concept of coffee drinkers globally, and SAM is the actual physical pool of potential customers I have access to based on my constraints.

Correct. But even SAM is a dangerous number to rely on. Why is that? Because it assumes zero competition and perfect visibility. Which is never the case. Exactly. And that brings us to the only metric that actually matters for survival. SOM, your serviceable, obtainable market. Okay, so what is SOM for the coffee shop? Out of all the coffee drinkers within a 5-mile radius, your SOM is the specific number of people who will realistically walk past your street corner, ignore the massive corporate coffee chain across the street, Right. Choose your shop, and actually buy a cup of your coffee given your current marketing budget and your seating capacity.

Is there a better way to picture market size?

So it's the real world. It is the brutal reality. Your business does not live in TAM. It barely even visits SAM. It survives entirely inside SOM. Okay. The source material uses a fishing analogy to explain this, like a guy in a giant ocean versus a guy in a small lake, but honestly, that doesn't quite click for me because, I mean, fish move around.

[03:53]Fair enough. I feel like evaluating market size is more like a gold rush. Like, TAM is a massive mountain range that geologists say contains $10 billion worth of gold. I like where this is going. And the SAM is the specific acre of land on that mountain. You actually hold the legal rights to mine. And the SOM is the amount of dirt you can actually move with the three shovels and one wheelbarrow you own before the winter snow hits. That is actually a much more accurate way to look at it, especially regarding the tools you have available.

Because you only have one wheelbarrow. Right. When a seller looks at a million monthly searches on Amazon, they are looking at the entire mountain range. They are confusing the total amount of money being spent in a category with the amount of money actually available for their specific wheelbarrow to take.

Can't a small seller live off the crumbs of a big market?

Wow. And the harsh reality is that the bigger the mountain range, the more aggressive the other mining operations are going to be. Okay, wait. Let's pause on that because I want to push back a little bit here. Sure. Even if I only have a wheelbarrow, a bigger mountain means more loose rocks, right? If a category is generating $100 billion a month, shouldn't there be enough residual crumbs falling off the table for a small seller to just scrape by and make a living? Why avoid the giant market entirely?

Because of what we call the cascade effect of large markets. Demand acts like a magnet. A magnet for what? For sophisticated capital. When a market shows massive, obvious search volume, it attracts apex predators. Oh boy. We aren't talking about other everyday sellers operating out of their garages. We are talking about private equity firms. We are talking about aggregator companies backed by hundreds of millions in venture capital. We are talking about international manufacturers deciding to just cut out the middleman and sell directly to the consumer. So I mean, I am literally just trying to sell a good product and I'm up against a Wall Street data center.

How do the big players squeeze small sellers out?

Basically, yes. So how are these predators specifically operating that squeezes the small seller out of those massive markets? Well, they weaponize their infrastructure. Let's look at pricing, for example. A small seller manually checks their competitor's prices, what, maybe once a day? If they're diligent.

[05:57]Yeah. A massive aggregator uses proprietary software connected via API that scrapes the market every 12 minutes. Every 12 minutes. That's insane. Right. And their algorithm dynamically drops their price by exactly $0.03 to steal the buy box during peak purchasing hours. Just to undercut you.

Exactly. While still maintaining profitability because their supply chain is optimized to the absolute penny, you just cannot manually outmaneuver an algorithm. So they basically just algorithmically bleed you out on price? Price is only one battlefield. The other is visibility. The ads? Yes. In a massive market, advertising costs, specifically your cost per click, just skyrocket because everyone is bidding on the exact same generic keywords. Because everyone wants to be on page one.

Right. And a private equity-backed competitor can afford to run their advertising at a loss for 18 straight months. Wait, really? Absolutely. They lose money on purpose. Absolutely. They will intentionally burn cash just to acquire customers and push you off the first page of search results. They are weaponizing their cash flow to starve you of visibility.

That is terrifying. If they can afford to lose money on ads until you go bankrupt, your theoretical market share drops to zero. Realistically attainable market share isn't dictated by your ambition. It's bounded by what you can defend. Exactly. It is strictly bounded by your SOM, meaning your inventory capacity, the efficiency of your advertising, your profit margins, and your available cash flow. Okay, so if the massive markets are essentially war zones where aggregators just burn venture capital to buy market share, where am I supposed to go? If I don't have a $50 million war chest, what is the alternative? You look where the algorithms aren't looking. Ooh, I like that.

Where should I look instead of the biggest markets?

The framework refers to this as reading Amazon backwards. Instead of sitting down at a research tool and asking, where are the most customers? You have to ask yourself, where are the most underserved customers? Underserved customers. Right. Unmet demand in a fragmented sub-market is infinitely more powerful than general demand in a crowded one. Okay, so we're looking for the sub-markets. The source uses the fitness category, which I actually think is fascinating. To a giant aggregator, the concept of fitness is just a massive spreadsheet of generic weights and yoga mats.

[08:20]Right. Just units moving. But fitness isn't actually a market at all, is it? No, not really. It is an umbrella term covering dozens of entirely separate ecosystems. You have competitive power lifters. You have traveling yoga instructors, physical therapists, indoor rock climbers, crossfit athletes, postpartum recovery fitness, adaptive sports for disabled athletes. All totally different needs. Exactly, every single one of those ecosystems has its own distinct vocabulary. They follow specific influencers, they have highly technical purchasing behaviors, and they have incredibly unique problems that a generic generalist brand simply cannot solve.

Why do customers pay more to a specialist?

I love the rock climbing example. Let's say I am dangling off the side of a 500 foot cliff. I need carabiners, ropes, and climbing chalk. Stakes are pretty high. Exactly. I could go on Amazon and buy that gear from a massive everything store brand, but this is a brand that is famous for making like discounted garlic presses, dog beds, patio furniture, and oh yeah, life-saving climbing rope. It doesn't inspire a lot of confidence. There is absolutely no way. As a consumer, I am actively avoiding the generalist.

I instinctively want the brand whose entire existence is obsessed with keeping rock climbers alive. You are illustrating the ultimate currency of commerce right there. Trust. Trust. Customers do not buy market size. A rock climber does not care that the generalist brand has a billion dollar TAM. They care about authority. Focus creates authority. Because you're speaking their language. Exactly. When your brand only speaks the language of a rock climber, you become the trusted specialist. And here's why that matters economically. Authority naturally creates pricing power. Because I'm not fighting an algorithmic price war over a garlic press.

[10:13]Exactly the opposite. Because the customer trusts your highly specialized carabiner more than the generic alternative, they are willing to pay a premium. Oh, right. They want the safety. That pricing power is what allows a niche business to achieve extraordinary healthy profit margins. You are stepping completely out of the margin crushing advertising war. You just opt out of the war entirely.

Yes. You are quietly serving a dedicated, somewhat paranoid community that happily pays you exactly what your expertise is worth. Okay, I see the logic of trust and pricing power makes sense, but let me play devil's advocate for a second, because I am struggling with the long term math here.

Isn't 1% of a huge market better than 30% of a small one?

Go for it. A $10 million niche category sounds tiny. If I am an ambitious entrepreneur or an investor, and I want to build a truly life-changing massive business doesn't focusing on a $10 million market artificially cap my potential. It seems like it would.

Right. Isn't it just better math to aim for 1% of a billion dollar market than 30% of a tiny one? I mean, 1% of a billion is a lot of money. That is probably the most common mathematical trap in business. Really? Yes. Owning 1% of a massive market gets you absolutely nothing. It is a complete myth that 1% of a huge pie makes you rich. Why is that a myth? Because in reality, at 1% you have zero brand recognition. Consumers don't search for your brand name, they just search for a generic keyword and click whatever is cheapest.

You are invisible. Ouch. But more importantly, you have absolutely zero influence over your supply chain. We unpack that for me. Why does my market share dictate my supply chain? Because factories prioritize production lines for their biggest buyers. If you own 1% of a massive market. Your order volumes are a statistical rounding error to your manufacturer. You're a nobody to them.

[12:07]Right. So if there is a global shipping crisis or a shortage of raw materials, the factory is going to fulfill the orders of the buyer who represents 30% of their revenue and they will completely ignore your 1% order. Wow. You have no leverage to negotiate better payment terms, no power to demand custom tooling, and zero protection against supply shocks. You are completely invisible and entirely vulnerable. But if I'm at 30% market share in a small niche, I am the whale to that specific factory.

Yes. Owning 30% of a focused $10 million market completely transforms the mechanics of your business. You dictate terms to suppliers because you are their most important client in that sector. You benefit from massive brand recognition within that specific community, which means you get organic repeat purchases and word of mouth referrals. You don't have to pay for every single click.

How does serving one niche build a moat?

Exactly. The goal of a business isn't to hold a tiny defenseless share of something huge. The goal is outright unassailable leadership. And the operational expertise you gain from that leadership creates a moat. A huge moat. The framework brings up commercial bakeries and I love this example. If my entire business is dedicated to serving commercial bakeries, think about the compounding knowledge I gain over, say, five years.

It's immense. I know there are specific local health regulations. I know there are seasonal buying cycles, like exactly when they have to ramp up for the holiday rush. I know the exact replacement cycles of their massive industrial mixers. Right. You transition from being a vendor who just sells physical items to being a vital partner in their actual workflow. You're a partner. Yes. A generalist who sells consumer baking sheets to random home cooks cannot just wake up one morning, decide to pivot, and compete with you on a commercial level.

They don't know anything about the holiday rush. They do not have the compounding knowledge. They don't know the pain points. Knowledge accumulates far too slowly when a business is just jumping between random consumer categories chasing search volume. Wait, if I'm dominating this tiny commercial bakery market, I'm not just selling the mixing bowls anymore, am I? I know their regulations, I know their pain points, I'm basically inside their kitchen.

Can a small market grow with my business?

[14:16]Exactly. Which leads right into the most surprising concept from the source material for me. These small markets don't actually stop growing. I always assumed that if you hit the ceiling of a $10 million market, you were trapped, but they naturally expand. They expand because they are built on a foundation of established trust. The original niche isn't a limitation, it is a launchpad. A launchpad? I like that. Consider the example of selling supplies to professional barbers.

Okay. If you go all in and dominate that niche by selling a highly specialized premium hair clipper, you don't just stop at clippers. You have earned the trust of the professional barber. You understand the ergonomics of their daily workflow better than anyone else does. So you naturally see the adjacent problems that they need solved. So you start making the specialized cleaning systems for those exact clippers. Yes. Then you expand into anti-fatigue floor mats for their stations, then maybe specialized scheduling software accessories, then professional apparel designed to repel hair.

You just own the whole barbershop. Exactly. Very few successful world-class brands started out by trying to serve everyone. That is a recipe for expensive mediocrity. Right. They became absolutely indispensable to one specific community first. One profession, one hobby, one distinct lifestyle. Start small, dig deep. Dominating that highly focused market created the capabilities, the cash flow, and the fierce brand loyalty they needed to eventually expand outward and consume those adjacent markets. It requires such a massive shift in perspective, doesn't it? You have to stop looking at those product research tools and asking, "How big is this market?"

What question should replace "how big is this market?"

And start asking yourself, "Can my business become the absolute best company in this market?" That's the golden question. One question encourages you to chase random crowded opportunities where you have absolutely no advantage. The other question forces you to build expertise, build a moat, and build a truly defensible business. And the great irony of business is that companies who become exceptional inside these small, highly focused markets almost always discover something unexpected years down the line.

[16:27]What's that? They realize that their market wasn't actually small to begin with. Only their initial definition of it was small. By the time they expand into all those adjacent categories and the broader market finally notices how dominant they have become, it is too late for the Apex predators to catch them. They already own the space. Wow. So as we wrap up this deep dive today, the core takeaway for you is this. Do not let massive search volumes and billion dollar TAMs blind you. The giant headline size is almost always a trap designed to bleed your capital. Completely. Real lasting opportunity is measured strictly by your SOM. What you can actually finance, what you can serve better than anyone else, and what you can defend against those algorithms and that venture capital.

Where else am I chasing the ocean instead of the lake?

Small, fragmented markets quietly produce massively profitable businesses because they allow you to step completely out of the ad bidding wars and build an unassailable advantage based on trust. I want to leave you with a final thought to chew on today. Let's hear it. We've talked extensively about how companies that become exceptional inside small markets often realize later that the market wasn't actually small, only their initial definition of it was. I challenge you to apply that beyond e-commerce. Oh, I like where this is going. What other areas in your life or your career are you avoiding right now?

Just because the initial headline size or the immediate audience seems too small to matter. Are you endlessly chasing overcrowded oceans in your own professional life, competing against thousands of others for a tiny slice of attention? When you could be dedicating yourself to dominating a quiet lake, where your unique skills would make you the undisputed leader. Man, that is powerful. Stop worrying about the size of the ocean and start looking for the lake where you can actually make an impact. Thank you for joining us on this deep dive. Keep questioning the obvious numbers. Keep looking for the underserved and we will catch you next time.